Grant Budgeting and Negotiating in India and China - Applied Clinical Trials

ADVERTISEMENT

  • Search
  • Suppliers
  • Careers

Enter a company or product name

KeywordLocation
About Search
See our 2009 Buyers Guide Digital Edition.
Find Pharma Search Engine
Grant Budgeting and Negotiating in India and China
Industry must grasp the cultural nuances of these two burgeoning countries to find success there.


Applied Clinical Trials


In 2000, there were 26 unique 1572s filed; this number increased to 76 in 2004 (0.2% of the global 1572 filings). Experts predict that by 2010 China will become the fifth largest pharmaceutical market and the world's third largest market by 2020.6 Simply put, China is the next frontier for pharmaceutical clinical trials and offers both opportunities and challenges for the pharmaceutical industry.

Investigator grant budgeting

Similar to India, investigator grant budgeting in China follows key practices that create a cost-friendly environment for clinical trials. For example:

  • Only public hospitals are allowed to participate in clinical research.
  • Most contracts are solely between the investigator and the hospital.
  • Budgets are built according to a local office's experience or sometimes according to headquarters' "gut feelings."
  • Most budgets are built on a cost-per-visit basis, although the costs for some expensive procedures, such as biopsies, are disclosed to the investigator as individual line items.

Procedures. On average, procedure costs in China are 39% of the cost in the United States (examples can be seen in Table 2). Procedure fees are hospital specific and almost all public hospitals provide the procedure costs to the public either in the hospital or online. However, these publicly available prices do not represent clinical costs and can only be used as one of the sources of information to begin budgeting.

Professional fees. Physician fees are usually budgeted per visit. The principal investigator decides if additional staff should be hired and whether study coordinator fees are paid on a per visit basis or on a monthly salary. Subject reimbursement is provided for patients who travel from a long distance and for invasive procedures. Pharmacy fees are often included in the contract with the hospital and include specific milestones. Infused medications are usually double or triple the cost for an oral or topical medication. On average, professional fees are 50% of the costs in the United States. Table 2 displays some specific examples.

Hospital fees. Administration fees are typical in hospital contracts. Hospital bed fees are used for surgical procedures. A "leading fee," in the form of a certain percentage, is applied for hospitals that are overseeing the study. Site costs are commonly included in the hospital contract.

Overhead. The investigator contract and the hospital contract may have two different overhead percentages. Overhead is applied to both the procedures and the professional fees (including both subject reimbursement and pharmacy fees) and can be presented as both overhead and administrative fees on budgets. Most contracts have an overhead of 10%.

Investigator grant negotiation

In China, budgets are almost always negotiated directly with the principal investigator and signed by the principal investigator and the hospital official, and sealed or stamped by the hospital. Study managers or CROs negotiate the contracts locally; the common negotiating currency is the yuan, although occasionally contracts are in dollars or euros.

Communication is key in successful negotiation in China. Compared to India, English is not as widely spoken in China; therefore, consistency and transparency are essential in presenting and negotiating the budgets.

Conclusion

Clearly, China and India are burgeoning regions for the pharmaceutical industry and represent what some have called "the industry's single biggest opportunity for growth." But realizing the promise both countries hold will take a full understanding of their clinical market community and their approach to budgeting and negotiating clinical trial contracts.

The rapid growth of clinical trials in both of these emerging economies and the array of local standards that can affect the bottom line will make it increasingly difficult for companies to operate in these countries without expertise in negotiation and budgeting. These particular negotiations are specific to the phase and complexity of the study as well as the site's experience and ability to execute the trial.

The clinical research community will also need to understand fully the areas of patient recruitment, trial monitoring, data collection and management, and statistical analysis of data generated from clinical trials in both countries. And even with a full understanding of these factors, pharmaceutical companies will need to rely on an industry aggregate of prices that enables them to realize the savings and efficiency inherent in clinical trials in China and India.


ADVERTISEMENT

ADVERTISEMENT

Enrollment Planning for Critical Path Studies
Conducting Trials in Croatia
To Market Faster In Silico Style
Is an Investigative Site Shake-Out Imminent?
EDC Acceptance in Japan
FindPharma
Survey
Would you ever consider working as a freelance clinical research professional?
Yes, I'd love to
Yes, but would never do it
No, but may have to
Absolutely not, no stability
Yes, I'd love to
75%
Yes, but would never do it
8%
No, but may have to
17%
Absolutely not, no stability
0%
View Results
Source: Applied Clinical Trials,
Click here